Mr Subs in Rahway employees are best Aleyah Melissa Tony Johnathan & Jason are the absolute best very kind friendly and professional ... Mr Subs in Rahway teamwork is phenomenal i love there work ethic

Not only the sandwich was good, but the 2 girls behind the counter were funny and very nice !!! If I go back will be because of them, the other kid just said, " I don't have to say anything" they do all the talking !! LOL Great experience!!!

July 2 2023. This the third time I've had the roast beef sub and pickle. Each time was better than the last. All very fresh. Certainly worth 5 stars. Marc K. in Rahway

Located at a small strip mall off on a busy Route 1-9 South in Rahway, some of my colleague have visited this establishment and enjoyed their sandwiches which I came for lunch. An order was placed over the phone with Mr. Subs for their 8" cold sub #11 Roast Beef and Turkey combo with Swiss cheese, oil, vinegar, lettuce and tomato. At the end of our conversation , my order would be ready in 5 minutes. Upon arrival, the place looked cozy whose menu was posted on the wall with a few tables for indoor dining. The manager, Odalis and his team greeted me with my order. The bread was soft and chewy. There was a decent amount of meat - not too much, boarderline too little. As a Yelp Elite, a discount was applied. All in all, I would order this again but wouldn't go out of my way.

Wow what a surprise! In the world of sandwich chains, I'm a Potbelly's guy. These are definitely better than Jimmy John's and Subway. This is based on delivery. We ordered two half sandwiches -- one Italian cold sub with jalapeño, banana peppers, hot relish and one roast beef & turkey cheese combo with jalapeño and Banana peppers. Yes, our home keeps it spicy during most meals, we know! All sammies seemed eight inches and hefty. I can't imagine what a whole sandwich is, to be fair. It would be larger than my torso! The portion note I do suggest is a touch more meat on the Italian. It felt thinnish. I do think the hot relish (which is their version of giardiniera?) added a hot crunch and more vinegary contrast to dense porcine deli meats. The bread is soft and I opted for whole wheat which had didn't sacrifice pillowy texture and even better, didn't give or collapse at the mega works of toppings and vinegar & olive oil I ordered. All in all, a half sandwich feels like two sturdy meals for one especially if you have chips with your order. I'll definitely order from them again! The delivery person was kind, followed directions, and was a swift delivery. 4.5 stars, really!

Thank you Nemo for your hospitality! Your servers were great. Thank you for the turkey sandwich, it was tasty and done quick and precise.

I ordered a half sub to-go for lunch last week. I got the Mr. Sub sub (#4), which has pressed ham, pepperoni, salami, and cheese (I went with provolone). You have a choice of white bread or wheat. I got my sandwich on white and with everything. "Everything" here means lettuce, tomato, onion, oil and vinegar, salt, pepper, and oregano. The sandwich was delicious! Fresh ingredients, great tasting bread, and just the right amount of oil and vinegar (no soggy mess here). The Rahway location is small. It's the middle shop in a three-shop, strip mall building. There's a small parking lot. It's right off of Route 1. If you drive down Paterson Ave to get here; it's on a cul-de-sac road. Even though the shop is small and there aren't many seats, the location doesn't skimp on the quality of its food. It's good for pick-up/to-go. The people behind the counter were really nice when I went, as well. I will definitely come back again when I am in the area. You should check it out!